Why US Congress Would Be Foolish To Pass Anti-Immigration & H-1B Visa Bill

I have read many articles in recent times since what is an anti-immigration and anti-H1B visa (and L-1 vis) legislation was submitted for debate in the US Congress.

The crux of the legislation is the ludicrous notion that 65,000 annual H-1B visas out of a workforce of over 150 million people (CIA figures) have helped be a major cause of the mass unemployment in the US. This equates to 0.4% of annual labor.

Then when you consider according to NASSCOM (National Association of Service and Software Companies), the average foreign engineer on H-1B visa only stays in the US for 2 years which is not even the full term of an H-1B visa which is 3 years.

Suddenly you see how ridiculous all this is and the arguments put forward by Senator Dick Durbin (D-IL) and Senator Chuck Grassley (R-IA) like;
“Some claim that the H-1B program helps to create American jobs, but it is currently being used by some companies to outsource American jobs to foreign countries.”

are all just an anti-immigrant and H-1B visa ruse to distract the US public from who is really to blame for the current  economy.

1. US Politicians who were in bed with corporate America and taking their kick backs, campaign contributions and gifts and providing little or no oversight over mass corruption and breaking of the law

2. US Corporations headed by US Executives (mainly in banking and financial sector) who engaged in practices that would mildly be described as extremely reckless while profiting individually regardless of the damage to their own companies or the general public who engage with them and economy as a whole

3, US Consumers for entering into mortgages they could not afford and racking up tens of thousands of dollars in credit card debt.

It almost reminds you of that Simpson’s episode where Mayor Joe Quimby distracts the public blaming the high taxes on immigrants and the public believes it. The sad thing today is that this is real life and not an animated cartoon on Fox.

For arguments sake lets suppose there proposition that the H-1B visa and immigrants are really taking jobs away from US citizens are argue that statements on its own merits by looking at the facts.

Duke & Harvard University Researcher Vivek Wadhwa who did a study for the Kauffman Group found:

  • Half of all Silicon Valley engineers are foreign born, up from 10 percent in 1970, where US innovation for the last 4 decades has stemmed from Apple and Microsoft to Yahoo and Google
  • About 40 percent of all U.S. patents go to immigrants.
  • These immigrant-founded companies employed 450,000 workers and generated $52 billion in revenue in 2005.

To  go further if that does not convince somebody Yahoo, Google, Sun, Intel, Audiovox, Qualcomm, and eBay – were founded and led by immigrants whose successful companies today employ hundreds of thousands of Americans.

Imagine if all those brands were Chinese, Indian or Heaven Forbid to many Americans, even Arabic where many of these hard working entreprenuers and innovators are from. Would the US even be in it’s top place in the world today?

The study also found that many of the highly educated foreigners who came to the US for undergraduate, graduate and PHD degrees to the top universties in the US paying hundreds of thousands of dollars in fees and spending each are chosing to return home because of the difficulty in obtaining an H-1B visa & more alarmingly the greater entrepreneurial opportunities back at home.

The New York Times recently profiled a young engineer for Google, Sanjay G. Mavinkurve, an Indian-born, American-educated entrepreneur who helped write the code for a website that would become Facebook. But now, Mr. Mavinkurve, who once proudly displayed an American flag in his college dorm room, must work in Canada because visa rules make it impracticable to move his wife and family to the United States.

Let me leave you with these final thoughts;

  • When Google built their moster Googleplex in Silicon Valley that seems to grow every day, how many American contruction companies and contractors built, extend and maintain that facility every day.
  • When the tens of thousands of Yahoo employees in Burbank go out for lunch each day to local eateries owned by hard working small businesses owned by Americans, how many US families does that feed.
  • At times like the upcoming Mother’s Day or Christmas, when millions of people all over the world purchase off eBay.com and eBay collects all that fee/commission revenue flowing into the US and then pays say 30% tax on their profits, how many roads does it build, young children does it feed and healthcare does it provide for (including Senator Durbin and Senator Grassley!!)

President Obama has signalled he doesn’t want the US to become an inward, protectionist nation. Well lets hope for all US citizens that holds true and this legislation does not pass as it would the first big dagger into US innovation and supremacy leading the world!


8 thoughts on “Why US Congress Would Be Foolish To Pass Anti-Immigration & H-1B Visa Bill

  1. You sound like a politician with that type of counter argument. No facts just ranting in the hope someone will believe you

  2. One more well written article by you. I totally agree with your thoughts. Keep up the good work 🙂

  3. quality01 you and million other ****EDIT**** americans like you dont see the pattern

    korean war
    vietnam war
    afghanistan USSR war (creation of the GOOD TALIBAN 🙂 Thanks to the US OF A!!
    gulf war – 1991
    war on terror -2001 – IRAQ,afghanistan
    coalition forces stationed in IRAQ 2002-present

    LARGEST economic CRISIS in US CORP history – sept 2008 lehman bros.

    Do you get it???????? ******EDIT REMOVED***********

  4. There is no need to call people names as that brings you down to their level. And while yes I agree tthere are many bad past deeds they have little or no relation to Immigration or the general US populace.
    For example elping to stop Milosevic in the Balkans was to many people I know a great thing as they lost loved ones and this has nothing to do with the current economic crisis.
    Many of those wars you mention are not solely and in some cases at all at the US’s fault. In any case this is about Immigration anyway and we should not get into name calling back and forth or we just end up replicating what goes on in Congress every day.

    And remember Pradip for you mean and the millions of others, if the US was such a bad country, why would we all want to come here? Criticism is good and important but it must be rational and fair minded so the causes of the problem attacked and not unrelated things.


  5. CJ you are right. I dont need to stoop as low as lawmakers and racists. In any case what I was pointing out was a pattern to how “self destructive” they have been and are being. There is a clear parallel between that and the way they did the economy both the greedy corp. ceos and few consumers. and then the way 0.4% of hardworking poor college students are made scapegoats just because they “payup” and “shutup” Oh and btw I love america, just love it so much just dont like the little whining useless racists who keep ranting H1B. pls get rid of illegal H1B abusing consultant firms not legal students and hardworking internationals.

  6. Hi Prad,
    Look I agree with most of you said but like you are doing, it is better to take the high road. You will go far and hopefully if enough immigrants and people like you go far enough, that eventually these type of Immigration laws are changed for future immigrants. Unfortunately the track record of the US is that as immigrant populations become established they tend to follow the xenophobic behavior of their predecessors but let’s hope that cycle changes!
    I wish you all the best in your life in America.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.